Where to Find Forex EAs and How to Properly Interpret Backtest Results
- Writer
- Nov 17
- 4 min read
In a previous article, we discussed the role of Forex Expert Advisors (EAs). Now, it’s time to find out where you can acquire these automated trading robots—whether for free or for purchase—and, more importantly, how to meticulously read their backtest results. Understanding these results is crucial before you commit any capital to an EA.
1. Top Sources for Downloading Forex EAs
Forex EAs, also known as trading bots, are widely available across various platforms and communities. Here are the most reliable places to start your search:
A. Within the MetaTrader Platform
Both MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5) feature a built-in "Market" section. This is often the first stop for traders, as you can directly browse, download, and install EAs—many of which offer both free and paid options.
B. MQL5 Market
As the official community platform for MetaQuotes (the developer of MT4/MT5), MQL5 offers an extensive marketplace. You can access it through the platform's Market tab or directly via the website: www.mql5.com.
C. Forexfactory
Forexfactory is a renowned hub for Forex traders, where members share knowledge and sometimes offer EAs for free or for sale. Crucially, the site often features community reviews, helping you gauge the quality and reliability of a bot before testing it.
D. Myfxbook
Myfxbook is a popular online platform that allows traders to track and verify their trading results. Many developers share their EAs here, often accompanied by verified trading statements, making it an excellent resource for performance monitoring.
E. CodeBase
This source is best suited for traders with programming knowledge. CodeBase provides free EA source code, allowing you to examine, modify, and build upon existing automation strategies.
F. Developer's Private Websites
Many professional EA developers operate their own websites to showcase and sell their products (like the one this article is hosted on). These sites often provide detailed performance reports and support. They may offer a mix of free and premium EAs.
G. Trader Community Groups
Joining trading groups on platforms like Telegram or Facebook can be a source of shared EAs. Be cautious, as the quality and safety of these free or IB-linked (Introducing Broker) shared EAs can vary significantly.
2. How to Interpret Backtest Results
Once you've found a potential EA, the next step is to scrutinize its backtest results. This data is the foundation of risk assessment.
A. The Summary Metrics
The backtest summary provides a quick overview of the EA’s historical performance.
The most basic performance metrics include the Total Net Profit, which must be positive (compare this to the initial deposit for a percentage return), the Gross Profit (total gains from winning trades), and the Gross Loss (total losses from losing trades).
A vital number to check is the Profit Factor, calculated by dividing Gross Profit by Gross Loss. This ratio measures the profit generated per dollar lost. It must be greater than 1.0; a strong EA typically boasts a Profit Factor of 1.5 to 2.0 or higher. Additionally, look at the Expected Payoff, which is the average profit or loss generated per trade—this should always be a positive value.
When assessing risk, focus on the Drawdowns. The Absolute Drawdown measures the maximum financial loss from the initial deposit. However, the most critical risk metric is the Maximal Drawdown. This represents the highest percentage reduction in account equity from any peak to a subsequent trough. It is essential that this percentage is within your acceptable risk limit, with values generally preferred to be below 20-30%. The Relative Drawdown is a similar measure, calculated as a percentage from the maximum equity achieved.
B. The Equity Curve Graph
The Equity Curve visually represents the change in your account balance over time. It is a fundamental tool for assessing an EA's stability.
A Healthy Graph: Should display a line that consistently climbs upwards at a steady, manageable slope. It should show periods of drawdown, but these must be shallow, brief, and followed by a quick recovery to a new equity high.
Warning Signs: Avoid curves that are overly steep (indicates high risk or over-optimization), flat or declining (indicates the EA is not profitable), or those showing deep and protracted drawdown (signals high risk and a slow, difficult recovery process).
3. Other Crucial Factors in Backtest Analysis
Beyond the core numbers, several external factors determine the credibility of a backtest.
A. Data Quality (Modeling Quality/History Quality)
The results are only as good as the data used to generate them.
For MT4, the Modeling Quality should be 99.90%. A lower percentage means the price data used was inaccurate, rendering the backtest results unreliable.
For MT5, the backtest should show 100% History Quality using real ticks.
B. Test Period
A short backtest period offers a narrow view of performance.
You should insist on seeing results that cover a long test period—ideally 3 to 5 years or more.
The test must cover a variety of market conditions (ranging markets, trending markets, high-impact news events) to ensure the EA is robust and not just successful in one specific environment.
C. Spread and Slippage
Most backtests run under idealized conditions. Backtest results typically use fixed spread values and often ignore slippage (the difference between the expected price and the execution price). In the real, live market, spreads are variable (especially during news events), and slippage is common. Always account for a worse performance in live trading than what the backtest shows due to these real-world market costs.
Comments